Review of Divergent Movie

Divergent Movie PosterNo spoilers of either the book or movie, I promise.  This is just my opinion.

This weekend, I saw the Divergent movie. Before I tell you what I thought of the movie, I will tell you two things: First, I loved this book. Second, it is very hard for me to like film adaptations of books that I have read and enjoyed.

Have you read Divergent? If you haven’t, you will enjoy this movie. I watched it with an adult male who does not read YA fiction and he said this was a great movie. It is fast paced and action-filled. Hailene Woodley, the actress playing Tris, does an excellent job of relaying emotion without reliance on dialogue which is very important in an adaptation of a book wherein we were privy to the thoughts of the main character. I suppose this is also a positive reflection on the screenwriters and director.

If you have read Divergent, you may not like this movie. At least one of my other YA reading friends is in outrage over it. The book is rich with character development and atmosphere. This film adaptation focuses all character ¬†development on Tris and Four to the detriment of everyone else. Even Peter, violent and unsympathetic oaf that he his, comes across as simple minded in the movie instead of the book’s coldly and calculatingly cruel. I am still somewhat torn over the creative reinterpreting of the conclusion of the climax, there are both good and bad changes there. We can discuss this in the comments below if you have thoughts on the matter. This was neither the best film adaptation of a book I have ever seen, nor was it the worst (by worst, I mean Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire).¬†I give it a 6/10, I would have scored it higher if there had been more depth to the other characters.

I am glad that I saw the movie on opening weekend. Watching it in a theater mostly full of teenage girls, I was able to enjoy it on another level. In a scene where Four asks Tris if she would like to see his tattoo (which involves removing his shirt), the audible reaction in the theater was, “YES!”

Review of the Matched Trilogy by Ally Condie

Reached by Ally CondieI recently finished reading the third and last book in the Matched trilogy by Ally Condie. I began reading this series because it was described as a readalike to the Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins. Well, it is…kinda. It is a YA dystopian novel set in a future where society has become corrupt and unreasonable. There is a lot that the Matched society has in common with Wells’ 1984. Society is always watching, listening, and controlling. Society tells you what your job will be, who you will marry, and when you will die. I don’t think it’s a spoiler to say that obviously the three main characters form a love triangle and succeed in overthrowing Society’s control by the end of the third book. That’s a common theme in dystopian YA. I will say that I enjoyed the first book much better than either of the two the followed. The second book indeed lived up to “second in a trilogy” stereotypes by being the least memorable. The conclusion was interesting, but entirely too perfect. All loose ends were tied up, all questions were answered, and everyone was happy.

I would recommend this book to people who found the romantic conflict within the Hunger Games trilogy highly interesting.